“Wild Bill” Donovan, “The Last Hero”

At the 11th hour of the 11th day of the 11th month of 1918, for the first time in over four years, the guns fell silent across the trenches that scarred the face of Europe during the First World War.  America had been latecomers to the conflict, but at a tremendous cost had tipped the scales in what had been a murderous stalemate.     No division had sacrificed more than the 42nd Division, nicknamed the “Rainbow Division ,” as it had been formed from National Guard Units whose origins streached across the country.  No unit in the Rainbow Division fought on more fronts, nor suffered more casualties, than the regiment that represented the green in that rainbow:  the 165th, the federal number assigned to the 69th New York.  It was the same 69th that fifty years earlier as a unit of the Irish Brigade had been given the nickname of “the fighting 69th” as a tribute of respect by an enemy commander, Robert E. Lee.    While the regimental number had changed, the unit and the New York Irish would once again prove worthy of that title, and no one was more responsible for the regiments unequaled record in WW I than Col. William “Wild Bill” Donovan.

Even before the war William Joseph Donovan was a hero of Horatio Alger proportions.  The grandson of immigrants from Skibbereen, Co Cork, he had literally been born on the wrong side of the tracks in Buffalo, New York.  Yet, as typical of Irish immigrants, each generation was climbing the long ladder of the American dream.  While Donovan’s grandfather had worked shoveling grain in the holds of ships, his father had risen to the influential position of yardmaster for the local railroad.  Young William Donovan continued the trend, attending Columbia University where he would earn a law degree.  Donovan was a star quarterback of the Columbia football team, where he earned the name “Wild Bill” in an age where amateur athletes were treated like today’s professional superstars.  He returned to Buffalo, started a law practice and married the daughter of the wealthiest man in Buffalo.

Donovan was not a man to rest on his success; his strong sense of duty and patriotism called him to seek an opportunity to serve his country.  With several friends, Donovan formed a National Guard company of cavalry that served when the Army was mobilized to hunt for Pancho Villa.  When the United States entered World War I, Donovan was called back to service and assigned as a major to the 165th regiment.  He was a popular choice with the mostly Irish American regiment, particularly their Chaplin, Fr. Francis Duffy who would go on to fame and honor in his own right with the regiment.  Donovan applied the same tough discipline on his men in training as he had applied to himself as an athlete at Columbia, training his men would learn to appreciate on the battlefields of France.

At the river Ourcq, nicknamed by the Irish of the 165th “the O’Rourke,” the 42nd Division had been ordered to cross the river and secure a ridge and farm on the other side.  The position was believed to be “lightly held” when in fact they were being faced by three German Divisions including one of elite Prussian Guards.  Only the 165th managed to reach its objective, the units on the left and right having fallen back.  The result was the 165th was cut off and subjected to machine gun and artillery fire on three sides.  It was estimated that the Germans had one machine gun for each four of Donovan’s men.  Donovan and his men held their position for three days, until the rest of the Division could reinforce the 165th but at a terrible cost:  of 3,000 men 1,750 men and 66 officers were lost.  Donovan himself was exposed to poison gas and wounded, yet still continued to lead his men.  In one case Donovan, without regard to danger, crossed open ground under heavy enemy fire to communicated coordinates for support artillery.  For this action Donovan was awarded the Distinguished Service Cross and promoted Lt. Colonel.

Tragically, these circumstances repeated themselves only a few months later when the 165th was asked to breach a line of German fortifications.  Again the 165th was going up against some of the best troops Germany had, but this time the 165th did not have the hardened veterans that Donovan had trained and had been lost at the Ourcq, but young and inexperienced recruits.  Describing it as foolish but necessary to his wife in a letter written before the battle, Donovan put on his full regulation uniform and insignia.  He knew that by being so obviously a senior officer he would be a target for German snipers, but also knew that his men needed to see him and he needed to be in front of them.  During the German attack, he was severely wounded, but continued to encourage his men refusing all attempts to evacuate him till the battle was over.  For this Donovan was awarded the Medal of Honor and became the most decorated soldier of WW I.

Despite having already accomplished enough to fill multiple lifetimes, history still had much more to write about “Wild Bill” Donovan, He would become a successful lawyer, federal prosecutor, and a confidant to Presidents for his clear and pragmatic thinking. Donovan was often used as a presidential agent, especially when it came to matters of foreign intelligence.  In World War II, he would create the Office of Strategic Services, the O.S.S., the precursor to the CIA, and attain the rank of Major General.  After the war, he would assist in prosecuting Nazi war criminals at Nuremberg.  Little wonder that when informed that William Donovan died peacefully after a life of honor and service to his country then President Eisenhower remarked “What a man! We have lost the last hero.”

Note:  For those who are interested in learning more about ‘Wild Bill Donovan’, Fr. Duffy and the 165th in World War I, the Division donated a book “Duffy’s War” to the Pearl River Library which is an excellent source on the topic.

Did You Know That?

  • William Donovan is the only American to have received our nation’s four highest awards, The Medal of Honor, the Distinguished Service Cross, the Distinguished Service Medal and the National Security Medal.
  • The Chaplain of the 165th, Father Francis Duffy is the most decorated Chaplain in the history of the United States Army. 
  • Rockland has a special connection to the 165th and World War I, Irish American Sgt. Michael A. Donaldson, a native of Haverstraw, was awarded the Medal of Honor for in one battle making six trips into “no man’s land”, exposing himself to machine gun fire to bring back wounded comrades.
  • Many years prior to WW I, Father Duffy said his first mass as a newly ordained priest at St. Peter’s in Haverstraw where he served till taking a teaching position at Dunwoodie.  The altar boy who assisted Fr. Duffy while at St. Peter’s was a very young Michael Donaldson.
  •  Though consider the “Father of U.S. Intelligence” and founder of the O.S.S, William Donovan was inexplicably passed over when it came time to create its successor organization, the CIA.  Some part of this decision was clearly motivated by interdepartmental rivalry, particularly J. Edgar Hoover of the FBI.  Others think an explanation may trace back to Donovan’s days with the 165th when Donovan made a blistering phone call to headquarters complaining about U.S. artillery support falling short and hitting his troops.  There is circumstantial evidence that the commanding officer of the battery that day was a captain from Missouri, Harry S. Truman.